The YEP was present and correct for each and every Leeds game this season, from the kick-off against Cardiff City, through those mid-season trips to Plymouth Argyle, to the bitter final whistle at Wembley. And for each game we produced player ratings, with the traditional mark out of 10 for every player who played enough minutes [10 or more] to qualify for subjective assessment.
First things first, though, the ratings are for want of a better word, a nightmare. It might be that a defensive midfielder’s work goes under the radar or is under-appreciated, because it’s the simple stuff. Even if it’s the simple stuff done well, it might not stand out quite as much to a spectator who is simultaneously crafting a match report and updating social media on every cough, lick and spit of a game, than a few thumping tackles from the full-back on the near side, or the eye-catching dribbles of a number 10. But the ratings, as a hugely popular mainstay of the YEP matchday coverage, are going nowhere.
What they do is paint a picture of who impressed, who did their job and who did not and when you zoom out to see the full picture at the end of the season then the general rule is that the best players end up in generally the right places when you rank them by their average rating. The usual caveats apply though. Those without a regular starting place will find it difficult to get a higher rating because they come into games that are either won or lost and find it hard to shine. Rhythm is key for so many players. Goalscorers tend to attract greater praise. And it must be noted that any player who features 40-plus times and ends up with a rating anywhere in the region of 7/10 has had themselves a very decent campaign.
It’s no surprise to see the likes of Crysencio Summerville and Ethan Ampadu at the top end of the list, but the main man according to the ratings this season might cause a debate or two. What cannot be argued is the consistency he brought to the table though, or his level of commitment even as a player Leeds do not own outright, yet. And it is precisely the consistent nature of his performances that make him a key target for the club for next season, if the numbers stack up with Tottenham Hotspur. So, by virtue of his numbers and the highest average rating of any player in the squad, centre-half Joe Rodon can now consider himself the Yorkshire Evening Post’s 2023/24 Player of the Year. Llongyfarchiadau.
First things first, though, the ratings are for want of a better word, a nightmare. It might be that a defensive midfielder’s work goes under the radar or is under-appreciated, because it’s the simple stuff. Even if it’s the simple stuff done well, it might not stand out quite as much to a spectator who is simultaneously crafting a match report and updating social media on every cough, lick and spit of a game, than a few thumping tackles from the full-back on the near side, or the eye-catching dribbles of a number 10. But the ratings, as a hugely popular mainstay of the YEP matchday coverage, are going nowhere.
![There's no doubt he can finish. There is serious doubt about which of the roles in a Farke system he can actually fill to everyone's satisfaction. Tidy footballer at times. Dangerman around the edge of the box. Not quite what was anticipated, or needed however, either at 9 or 10.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/52/Joel%20Piroe.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
25. Joel Piroe - 5.9
There's no doubt he can finish. There is serious doubt about which of the roles in a Farke system he can actually fill to everyone's satisfaction. Tidy footballer at times. Dangerman around the edge of the box. Not quite what was anticipated, or needed however, either at 9 or 10. | Getty Images
![Chances were so few and far between and injuries had their say. A bit of a nothing season for the youngster, who really needs gametime now, anywhere, to kick start what was such a promising career.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/08/Joe%20Gelhardt.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
26. Joe Gelhardt - 5.9
Chances were so few and far between and injuries had their say. A bit of a nothing season for the youngster, who really needs gametime now, anywhere, to kick start what was such a promising career. | Getty Images
![Didn't happen for him, again, at Leeds. This season was the last chance saloon but he ended up at Wednesday on loan and they seemed to like him. There's lots of skill and talent there, but he needs to make something of it now.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/31/Ian%20Poveda.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
27. Ian Poveda - 5.9
Didn't happen for him, again, at Leeds. This season was the last chance saloon but he ended up at Wednesday on loan and they seemed to like him. There's lots of skill and talent there, but he needs to make something of it now. | Getty Images
![There were some really difficult outings, a few solid ones but ultimately he lost his place and didn't ever look like he'd get it back. The loan move to Middlesbrough had the desired effect of winning him a contract elsewhere. Will always retain a fond place in Leeds fans' affections.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/55/GettyImages-1693533611.jpg.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
28. Luke Ayling - 5.8
There were some really difficult outings, a few solid ones but ultimately he lost his place and didn't ever look like he'd get it back. The loan move to Middlesbrough had the desired effect of winning him a contract elsewhere. Will always retain a fond place in Leeds fans' affections. | Getty Images
![Another for whom the summer will provide time for a good, hard think. For whatever reason he was unable to force Farke's hand, even when there were injuries at centre-half. And there was little argument whatsoever for dropping Rodon. Needs gametime next season. But where?](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/36/Charlie%20Cresswell.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
29. Charlie Cresswell - 5.8
Another for whom the summer will provide time for a good, hard think. For whatever reason he was unable to force Farke's hand, even when there were injuries at centre-half. And there was little argument whatsoever for dropping Rodon. Needs gametime next season. But where? | Getty Images
![A nightmarish start to the season, from which he never really recovered. Ended up leaving the club to seek his fortune elsewhere.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2024/06/13/10/57/Leo%20Hjelde.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=800)
30. Leo Hjelde - 4.8
A nightmarish start to the season, from which he never really recovered. Ended up leaving the club to seek his fortune elsewhere. | Getty Images